Please read the following article at petside.com  http://www.petside.com/article/memorial-day-weekend-celebration-owner-has-caboodle-ranch-cats-returned

IMPORTANT NOTE:  The information in this post came from the story at petside.com (see above link) and from a good friend of Nanette’s who was present when the cats were returned to her.  I have not personally seen the cats, the scars or the  papers from the ASPCA.

As I mentioned in a previous blog, a wise and just judge awarded Nanette Entriken’s cats back into her custody!  That decision was made almost two weeks ago, but on Wednesday, May 23,   Nanette was finally able to bring her cats home for the first time since they were confiscated a few days following the raid by the ASPCA and the Madison County, Florida Sheriff’s Department on Caboodle Ranch at Lee, Florida.   What the County of Madison, the Madison County Sheriff’s Department and the ASPCA did to Nanette was cruel and unconscionable. Throw PeTA in the mix as well since it was a video manufactured by a slick, slimy PeTA spy that motivated the carefully orchestrated raid (carefully orchestrated possibly to make a damaging impact against the passage of FARA, the proposed Florida Animal Rescue Act which was up for ratification.)

Nanette told a reporter at Petside.com,  that when she  picked up her cats Wednesday, she discovered to her horror that invasive exploratory surgery had been done on all of the females, supposedly to determine if they had been spayed or not; this included Nanette’s 15 year old spayed female.  Now, if this is indeed true, the ASPCA was aware, or should have been aware that Nanette had all the medical records on hand for her cats and they could have had access to these records by either asking her or her lawyer.  By the way, according to Nanette,  all her female cats had been spayed except for a couple of females too young for the surgery at the time of their confiscation.

Let me digress a bit for those of you unfamiliar with the case.  The poor woman, Nanette Entriken,  had moved to a trailer home on Caboodle Ranch property TWO WEEKS prior to the Caboodle Ranch raid.  Nanette had been maintaining the website for the ranch from her home in North Carolina and had made the drive down to Florida monthly to work hands on with the cats.  It was her dream to move to Florida and actually work with the care of the cats on a daily basis.  This move was accomplished in late February, 2012 when she moved along with her cats to a trailer home on Caboodle Ranch property.  Although Nanette said said her cats had never mingled with the Caboodle Ranch cats or been out of her home and although she said she was assured by the Sheriff that she would not be charged and her cats would not be involved, the Sheriff’s dept. showed up on her doorstep early one morning a few days later and confiscated them all. Nanette said when she went down to the Sheriff’s Dept. to try to get them back, she was met from a representative from the State’s Attorney’s office who told her cruelly, “it will be a long time before you see your cats again. They are state’s evidence.” STATE’s EVIDENCE although they had been in the county two weeks! Later, papers were filed by the State’s Attorney’s office to take custody of her cats on the grounds that she was “unstable and unfit to care for them.” If there ever was a travesty of justice, if ever a person was unjustly victimized, traumatized and tormented by a legal system gone completely insane, this is the perfect example. I’m glad justice and common sense prevailed and she was awarded her cats back. When I found out just now about Nanette’s allegations of  unnecessary surgeries, that really made me angry.  If this is truly confirmed and can be proven, then the  ASPCA should not get away with it. Personally, I have not seen the cats, the scars or the papers from the ASPCA, but why would Nanette lie about something like this and risk bringing the wrath of the ASPCA down on her?

Please realize this is just one case out of thousands. Whether this can be proven or not, this kind of abuse of power by animal “rights” groups is happening every day in this country. No group or organization, especially radical animal “rights” activists should have the apparently limitless power they have to disrupt and ruin the lives of people and animals any time they so choose.

Source:  http://www.petside.com/article/memorial-day-weekend-celebration-owner-has-caboodle-ranch-cats-returned

Incidently, in my first post I stated that if proof was not forthcoming from Nanette, I would take the post down and make apologies to the ASPCA.  I took my original post down and replaced it with this one.  That part of the bargain was kept.  As for the ASPCA, this is my apology.  I’m sorry I did not email you earlier than I did, but you have received both a message and an email from me.  I would appreciate  an answer, and welcome comments and documents from you showing your side of the story.

The respose from the ASPCA did come Monday, June 4 in an email to me from Olivia Melikhov.  The email reads as follows:

Thank you for reaching out to us. We did have a very important correction to the Petside.com story, which we posted in the article comments section. The female cats were shaved simply to check first for spay scars so that unnecessary and intrusive surgery could be avoided. Only in one instance, where a scar was not apparent upon close examination by two veterinarians, was a previously spayed cat surgically opened. Her previous spay was quickly confirmed, and she was re-sutured and is doing well.

Please let me know if you  have any other questions.
All the best,




  1. I’m a friend of Nanette’s. She is very thankful that her ordeal is over. She does not have internet and rely’s on me to let her know what is being said. She has asked me not to tell her anymore negative things. She is trying to get on with her life…with her cats. She doesn’t have to prove to anyone what the ASPCA did or didn’t do. She is done having to prove anything. She’s not about to show anyone her cats papers. She doesn’t have to. She wants this all to end. For now, she is busy taking her cats to the vet due to hernia’s and other ailments they endured during their time spent at with the ASPCA. She has notes written from the ASPCA telling her to take this one and that one to the vet due to this or that. There were no hernia’s when the cats were taken. No one gave them permission to touch HER CATS! One cat had to go thru withdrawals from her anxiety meds and endure a surgery that she didn’t have to have! Her cats were all healthy when they were taken from her. She has gone through more than a person can imagine. She only wants to be left alone. She is very very grateful to her supporters. Only they truly understand and respect her. The haters out there (and you know who you are) spreading lies and slander on Nanette….all of you can go to Hell. Yes, I said it. Hell! You have never met Nanette. You have no idea what a kind and loving person she is! She did nothing wrong…except move to Madison County.

  2. Nanette mentioned after judge’s decision was made to return the cats to her… only four of her female cats have not been fixed. Four! That many cats should have had the surgery done, not all. But this shows you where we are. One has no voice even if it is backed up with organized files about each and every cat. Money talks and larger groups are always in the lead. Keep donating smaller groups! They do the hard work!

  3. I had this story reviewed by a journalist who has confirmed it’s legality. No further comments will be allowed on this post and I will not allow myself to be intimidated by threats from the torch and pitchfork totin’ anti-Caboodle Ranch hate gang again. Further comments from the ASPCA are welcomed and will be published.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s